Moon Formation Challenged

January 11, 2017

The formation of the Moon has remained something of a puzzle. A leading theory proposes a cataclysmic impact involving a Mars-sized object and a young Earth. But there are some inconsistencies with this scenario. Based on hundreds of simulations run on a computer cluster, a new study from the Weizmann Institute of Science just published in Nature Geoscience, suggests a more plausible chain of events might involve a number of run-ins with smaller objects. This would have produced smaller moonlets, eventually coalescing into the single Moon we have today.

According to research student Raluca Rufu and Professor Oded Aharonson of the Weizmann Institute’s Earth and Planetary Sciences Department, the accepted explanations for the formation of our Moon rely on highly specific initial conditions e.g. a collision with an object of a particular size traveling at a defined velocity and hitting Earth at a specific angle.

Furthermore, in a typical impact, different proportions of that object would have ended up in the Earth and the Moon, leaving a detectable difference between the bodies. But various chemical analyses of the Moon’s makeup, taken from samples returned by astronauts, reveal that it is nearly identical to that of Earth. In other words, there is no trace of the large body that supposedly hit Earth, and the theories, say the researchers, turn out to be improbable.

Rufu and Aharonson, together with Dr Hagai Perets of the Technion – Israel Institute of Technology, asked whether a number of smaller collisions might better explain what happened several billion years ago, when the solar system was taking shape. Such smaller bodies would have been more prevalent in the system, and thus collisions with the smaller objects would have been more likely.

Small, high-velocity collisions could also mine more material from Earth than a single, large one. In addition, explained Aharonson, if a number of different bodies collided with Earth over a period of millions of years, their different chemical signatures – for example, ratios of oxygen-16 to its heavier cousins, oxygen-17 and -18 – might even out, masking the traces of the various collisions.

The collisions – with small planets one tenth the mass of Earth to space rocks the size of the Moon, a hundredth the mass of Earth – would have sent clouds of rubble, melt and vapor into orbit around the early Earth. These, according the simulations the scientists created, would have cooled and agglomerated into small moonlets that, in time, could have merged into one.

To test this scenario, the group ran around 800 impact simulations on the Weizmann Institute of Science’s Chemfarm cluster, which has more than 5000 processor cores.

“The new scenario does not require finely tuned initial conditions and if the smaller moonlets, as we think, were drawn into the same orbit, they could have merged over millions of years,” said Rufu.

“We are now running further simulations to try to understand how the smaller moonlets produced in these simulations might have coalesced to form our Moon,” concluded Aharonson.

Professor Oded Aharonson’s research is supported by the Benoziyo Endowment Fund for the Advancement of Science; the Helen Kimmel Center for Planetary Science, which he heads; the Minerva Center for Life under Extreme Planetary Conditions, which he heads; the J & R Center for Scientific Research: and the Adolf and Mary Mil Foundation.

 

Previosly
Bats Remember Directions
January 13, 2017

More Research

Bread and Health: A Personal Matter

Bread occupies a unique place in our diet: it accounts for about one-tenth of the calories many people in the West consume and up to 40% of the caloric consumption…

eastRead More

Imaging Study Finds Unique Brain Patterns Among Autistic

Unfortunately, Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) remains a condition that presents more questions than answers. Some studies have found a lack of connection or synchronisation between different parts of the brain…

eastRead More

Upping Oxygen Levels Could Reduce Jet Lag

New Weizmann Institute of Science research just published in Cell Metabolism and reported in the Times of Israel plus other media, has found that changes in surrounding oxygen levels can reset…

eastRead More

Snakes on the Brain

Researchers now can say what would happen in Samuel L. Jackson’s brain if he really were to confront snakes on a plane. In a terrifying sequel to that movie scenario, researchers convinced…

eastRead More

View All